| 1816 ? |
Jacob Drake (1st Mayor) |
| |
Walter VanHorn * |
| 1824 |
M. D. Pettibone |
| 1830 |
Noah Spalding |
| |
Charles Neil....d 1882 * |
|
After 1849 Mayor was
elected by City Council |
| 1857 & 1858 |
Charles Henry McElroy |
| 1859 |
James A. Barnes |
| 1864?? |
John Sills Jones....d 1903 * |
| 1867 to 1869 |
VanDeman |
| 1869 to 1871 |
Archibald Lybrand, Jr. |
|
Delaware became a City, Mayor elected by
the people |
| 1872 to 1874 |
John D. VanDeman (R) |
| 1874 to 1876 |
William Oliver Semans (Temp) |
| 1876 to 1878 |
J. A. Barnes (R) |
| 1878 to 1880 |
Charles Henry McElroy (R) |
| 1880 to 1882 |
Frederick Merrick Joy (R) |
| 1882 to 1885 |
H. L Baker (D), two terms |
| 1886 to 1890 |
H. E. Buck (D) * |
| 1888 |
J. K. Newcomer (D) * |
| 1890 to 1894 |
Harry S. Culver (R) two terms |
| 1894 to 1896 |
H. L. Baker (D) third term |
| 1896 to 1898 |
Wilfried Renaldo Carpenter (R) |
| 1898 to 1902 |
John McClure (D), two terms |
| 1902 to 1906 |
H. C. Clippinger (R), two terms |
| 1906 to 1908 |
H. H. Beecher (R) |
| 1908 to 1912 |
William E. Haas (D), two terms |
| 1912 to 1914 |
Bert V. Leas (D) |
| 1914 to 1916 |
John Louis Anderson(R) |
| 1916 to 1920 |
Arthur James White (R) |
| 1920 to 1924 |
Walter Samuel Pollock (R) |
| 1924 to 1928 |
Howard Rezen Pumphrey (R) |
| 1928 to 1934 |
Fred C. Johnson (R) |
| 1934, resigned |
Veley Main (D) |
| 1934 to 1938 |
Sidney Archie Rowland (D) |
| 1938 to 1940 |
Hosea A. Spaulding (R) |
| 1940 to 1942 |
Paul B. White (R) |
| 1942 to 1944 |
Hosea A. Spaulding (R) |
| 1944 to 1948 |
Patrick Joseph Foley (D) |
| 1948 to 1952 |
Ansel Lockhart (R) |
| 1952 to 1954 |
Murton F. Pinney (R) |
|
Council Manager Form of Government
Began |
| 1954 to 1956 |
Paul Bale White |
| 1956 to 1957 |
Edward Flahive |
| 1958 to 1959 |
Paul B. White |
| 1959 to 1961 |
Henry Wolf |
| 1961 to 1963 |
Paul B. White |
| 1963 to 1965 |
Donald Mathews |
| 1965 to 1969 |
Robert Ray Newhouse |
| 1969 to 1971 |
Gilford E. Easterday |
| 1971 to 1973 |
John Jeisel III |
| 1973 to 1977 |
Gilford E. Easterday |
| 1978 to 1981 |
Donald Wuertz |
| 1982 to 1983 |
Donald Worly |
| 1984 to 1985 |
Michael Shade |
| 1986 to 1989 |
Donald Wuertz |
| 1990 to 1993 |
Michael Shade |
| 1994 to 1995 |
Dennis Davis |
| 1996 to 1999 |
Juliann Secrest |
| 2000 to 2002 |
Tommy W. Thompson |
| 2002 to 2009 |
Wendell Wheeler |
| 2010 to |
Gary Milner |